Category Archives: Government

Political Rallies in Hilo & Honoka’a

We attended a large, two-part political rally this weekend. The first part was held at ‘Imiloa Astronomy Center in Hilo, and the second at a school cafeteria at Honoka‘a. We were asked to set up a display of our vegetables at both places.

Highlights were:

  • Senator Inouye’s powerful support for gubernatorial candidate Neil Abercrombie
  • Senator Akaka’s singing of the song “Where I live there are rainbows,” and
  • Neil Abercrombie’s emotional speech talking about how our diversity is what unites us, not divides us.

The main people in attendance were Senator Inouye and Senator Akaka, Representative Maizie Hirono, Neil Abercrombie and Lieutenant Governor candidate Brian Schatz. Also present were Senator Russell Kokubun and Representatives Jerry Chang, Faye Hanohano, Clift Tsuji, Cindy Evans and Mark Nakashima.

Mayor Billy Kenoi introduced the speakers at ‘Imiloa, and Senator Dwight Takamine introduced them at Honoka‘a.

IMG_0376

Neil Abercrombie has a very quick wit and strikes me as a really good guy. This is Tracy and Kimo with Neil and I.

IMG_3104

In the next photo, that’s June and Maizie Hirono. I grumbled at Maizie’s chief of staff, Anne Stewart, about why geothermal was not mentioned in her campaign ad. Anne said it was inadvertent; because the folks who did the ad were separate from the campaign.

IMG_0394

This is a picture I’ve wanted to capture for many years. It is of Senator Dan Inouye, President Pro Tem of the United States Senate, and Monty Richards, national officer of the Republican Party. These two men have been partners in the effort to transition Hawai‘i’s agriculture after sugar’s demise in the early 1990s. Monty, a knowledgeable farmer and rancher, worked with Senator Inouye to develop and administer the Regional Economic Transition Assistance Hawaii program (RETAH). They are good friends and often kid each other about belonging to the opposite political party.

They worked together to make the transition happen. And they were successful. Today ag is worth more than it was when the plantations shut down.

IMG_0404

Governor candidate Neil Abercrombie and Lt. Governor Candidate Brian Schatz at the Honoka‘a rally. Senator Inouye gave a powerful endorsement of Neil Abercrombie.

Abercrombie gave a rousing and emotional speech about unity, trust and hopefulness. I had never felt so much emotion run through a room after a political speech as I heard then.

It made me feel like we are absolutely going to be successful in getting geothermal on line as the primary base power for the Big Island. At one point, I glanced over at Mayor Kenoi and felt like we were thinking the same thing, at the same time, about geothermal: “Not, no can. CAN!” And it made me feel that it will happen for the right reasons – because it is the right thing to do for the “rubbah slippah folks.”

IMG_0399

Hamakua Springs set up a display as part of the festivities at the ‘Imiloa rally, as well as the one at Honoka‘a.

IMG_0364

Bob Stanga had a nice assortment of the mushrooms they grow.

IMG_0357

Roger Hirako and some of the best of his Kamuela Grown products.

IMG_0391

Keeping the kids occupied.

IMG_0366

Farmers Not In Favor of Pasha Entering Inter-Island Barge Service

From the Star-Advertiser article:

Pasha gets PUC approval for interisland shipping
By Star-Advertiser staff

POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Sep 21, 2010

The Public Utilities Commission has authorized Pasha [Hawaii Transport Lines LLC] to operate between Honolulu, Kahului, Hilo, Nawiliwili, Barbers Point and Pearl Harbor through Dec. 31, 2013. The commission will then evaluate the effects of the service and make a final decision on the company’s request to operate in the market permanently.

Young Bros. argued that Pasha will only serve the biggest ports and the most lucrative lines such as autos, heavy equipment and construction materials. Young Bros. also said that Pasha will “cherry-pick” the most lucrative routes and could harm local farmers and cattle ranchers who receive discounts subsidized by higher rates on other goods…. Read more

I think that allowing Pasha to operate in the inter-island barge service, without forcing them to provide the same services that Young Brothers provides, will jeopardize Hawai‘i’s food security.

Young Brothers gives locally grown products a 30 percent discount. They are not forced to do it; they worked with farmers to come up with that rate. And Young Brothers services the ports at Moloka‘i, as well as Lana‘i. Pasha will not be servicing those ports, nor moving agricultural products.

Farmers know that food security involves farmers farming. And that if farmers make money, farmers will farm. Young Brothers helps farmers to make money.

It is clear to us that if Young Brothers’ profitability is at stake, they will be forced to rethink the farmers’ discount. That is not good for farmers.

Farmers are not in favor of allowing Pasha to unfairly compete with Young Brothers.

Elizabeth Warren, A Hero

More than a year ago, before Elizabeth Warren was head of the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), and before the position as head of the new Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection existed, I wrote that she was one of my heroes.

This New York Times opinion piece says: “President Obama should nominate Elizabeth Warren to head the new Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection, and not only because of her credentials.”

I like her because she is smart and has common sense. The other side, though, is fighting her tooth and nail. Can we rely on their judgment when they bungled things so badly?

Warren is an outspoken critic of America’s credit economy, which she has linked to the continuing rise in bankruptcy among the middle-class. Here is a video of her talk at UC Berkeley.

From my previous post about her:

Her talk covers much more than that, though. [Editor Leslie’s note: I just sat and watched that entire one-hour video, practically without blinking. I didn’t have time to, but it is fascinating and I watched it all the way to the end. I highly recommend it.]

Some of her points: In the 1970s, a married couple with two kids had one parent in the workforce and saved 11 percent of their income. To get into the middle class, their kids needed to get a high school diploma and to be willing to work hard. That 12 years of education that their children needed, to get into the middle class, was free.

Warren says that the most important thing that happened in the first two-thirds of the 20th century was that women entered the work force.

In the 2000’s, a similar married couple with two kids must have two people in the work force – because, she says using numbers adjusted for inflation, median mortgage payments in 2005 are 76 percent higher than they were in 1970. Health insurance – in a healthy family with employee-sponsored health insurance – costs the family 74 percent more. Childcare costs have increased 100 percent, and as compared to the 1970s family a 2000s family has the expense of a second car because of that second person in the workforce, and because of that second income their tax rate is up by 25 percent.

In comparable dollars, the 2005 family is actually spending much less on clothes, food, appliances and cars than the 1970s family did; it’s the non-flexible, big ticket and important expenses that have increased so dramatically and that require that second income.

So a comparable married couple with two kids in 2005 has no savings (compared to the 1970s couple, who saved 11 percent of their earnings), and 15 percent of their income is in credit card debt as they try to keep up.

To launch their kids into the middle class requires 16 years of schooling, and the 2005 family has to pay  for the first two years (preschool) and the last four years (college) themselves.

She also discusses how, compared to the 1970s, hospitals now send people home “quicker and sicker” (their phrase, she says) in order to control costs, and the family is shown how to and expected to care for, say, a post-surgery patient themselves. Which generally requires someone taking time off work.

And there is so much more on that video. It is a real eye-opener.

Governor Lingle and Grandma

Governor Linda Lingle came to visit us at the farm a couple of days ago.  The first thing I wanted to be sure of was that Grandma would be there. And I wanted to tell the governor that we could not have done this without June’s help and support.

Grandma & the governorKimo and Tracy Pa on the left; June and I on the right. Three generations of us in front of the camera. Our grndson Kapono Pa, the fourth generation, is behind the camera.

In the picture, I think Grandma and the governor have their arms around each other, and June is holding Grandma’s other hand. That made me smile.

First we went to see the tomato packing house workers, and the varieties of tomatoes we grow. I explained that our view of sustainability involves our workers, our community and the environment; and that food security is about farmers farming. “If farmers make money, farmers will farm.”

Lingle
The Governor loves Hamakua Springs tomatoes

Ted Liu, Director of the Department of Business Economic Development and Tourism, asked me to give the governor an overall view of our farm. I explained that we have approximately 60 workers and that the farm consists of 600 fee simple acres in production. We have an annual rainfall of 140 inches and we have three springs and three streams running through the property. On our farm, we have the equivalent of about one-thirds of the water that flows through the Waiahole ditch to supply the Ewa Plains on O‘ahu. And we are in the process of building a hydro-electric plant, which will provide all the farm’s electricity. It will be able to continuously power fifteen 40-foot Matson reefers.

I explained that we started banana farming by trading banana pulapula for chicken manure and that we have transformed our business many times in our 30 years of business. So transforming ourselves is second nature to us.

When gas prices went up in mid-2008, several of our workers asked to borrow money for gas. That was very worrisome.

So we are transforming ourselves again. Instead of being the only large farmer on 600 acres, we are leasing land to area farmers. In the future, we won’t have many workers that live far away. And we won’t need to worry about workers’ housing.

We are offering area farmers a reasonable rent, and we are intending to provide water and electricity to the farmers at a very reasonable price. We know that if the farmers can make money, the farmers will farm. And if they make money, then we can make money distributing their products and then the retailers will get a steady supply of product to feed Hawai‘i’s people. With cheap electricity from the hydro plant, we can control our, and the farmers’, cooling costs.

Group We grow tomatoes, bananas, herbs and lettuces. Other farmers grow cucumbers, apple bananas, sweet corn, sweet potatoes and ginger. In addition, we market papaya, lemons, limes, longan, lychee, heart of palms and more.

We went over to look at the tilapia we are experimenting with. We think that in a future of rising oil prices, fish food will not be cheap and transporting frozen fish around the world will be expensive. So we are experimenting with growing fish using free running water, so we won’t need to use electricity for aeration or hormones and antibiotics. We are experimenting with using waste from our farm operations for feed. At some point in the future, this will become economical to do. We have all the natural resources and the vegetable waste to use. We plan to use the fish waste for fertilizer for downstream plants. When the time is right, we can scale up to any size that makes sense.

We went back to the main packing house, where June introduced the governor to some of the farmers, who then had a chance to chat with her. I explained that Kimo Pa is the farm manager, and that he and our daughter Tracy represent the next generation of farmers.

Lingle & ida castillo
Governor Lingle with Ida Castillo

I told the governor that we are pushing for geothermal by having community meetings and talking to people, as we did early on for the TMT. She agreed that geothermal makes a lot of sense and said she would support us.

She mentioned to Ted Liu that we were “actually doing it.” I took it to mean that she thought we are doing something about Hawai‘i’s food security, rather than just talking about it. It was a nice, pleasant visit that we all enjoyed.

What is Plan B? Plan C?

Do you remember that prior to the climate change conference this past December, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) declared that greenhouse gases endanger human health? I heard it!

This means that, at anytime, the EPA can declare greenhouse gases – including C02 – are harmful to human health, and it could impose penalties.

The U.S. Congress is now getting ready to pass climate change legislation. Whatever they pass, our electric utilities will likely be penalized for emitting C02 – whether they burn fossil or biofuel.

This is why I ask: “What if the EPA designates C02 a dangerous gas? What is Plan B? Plan C?”

I’ve also been noticing that Europe and now the East Coast of the U.S. are slowly coming to the conclusion that biomass is not C02 neutral. In fact, they are finding that it could be as harmful as coal as far as C02 emissions are concerned.

It turns on if it is used for collecting and burning waste branches and rubbish, instead of trees. It also has to do with how long the rotation of new trees takes. Hu Honua is planning to burn eucalyptus trees, which might put it in the EPA’s gun sights. Organizations need to be out in front of these issues.

To be clear, I am in favor of PV, wind, algae and biofuels for transportation. What I am talking about here, though, is “base power” for electricity. “Base power” is the largest part of the electric utilities’ usage.

I also believe that each grid needs to find its own solution. I am mostly talking about the Big Island grid.

Which brings us back to this Lloyd’s of London white paper I just wrote about here. The world has changed and yesterday’s decisions may not be applicable to tomorrow’s reality.

It is no secret that I believe that geothermal moves us out of the line of fire.

I believe that the changes coming upon us, as the Lloyd’s of London analysis points out, are serious and will take place before any geothermal event.

We will soon find out who our true leaders are.

Department of Agriculture to the Rescue

Here are two very significant examples of biological control in action here in Hawai‘i:

Several years ago, the stinging nettle caterpillar was found a couple of miles from where we live in Panaewa.

Its stinging, spiny hairs have a physical effect on human skin similar to that of fiberglass. The spines also release an irritant (a mixture of histamines) produced by a poison gland, which causes the skin to burn and itch. Fruit growers were afraid that, left uncontrolled, this insect could put their workers in danger.

“The detection of nettle caterpillar in Hawai`i quickly set HDOA on a mission to find a natural enemy that would be specific to that particular pest,” said Sandra Lee Kunimoto, Chairperson of the Hawai`i Board of Agriculture.  “Although this pest was not well known in the world, our entomologists were able to find and test a tiny wasp that preys on the stinging caterpillar and nothing else found in Hawai`i.”

Another example was the highly successful biocontrol program for the Erythrina gall wasp, which resulted in the rebounding of the native wiliwili trees.

Both of these accomplishments took a lot of hard work and went largely unnoticed by the general public, but they were very significant and have been very important to Hawai‘i.

Sandy Kunimoto should be proud of the Department of Agriculture’s accomplishments in this area. I am.

Who Will Be Our True Leaders? We’ll See

Who will be our true leaders?

From International Energy Association data, we know that future oil supply will start to decline in a very short time. Oil fields age and decline naturally. It is estimated that all the world oil fields combined decline in production at the rate of 4 million barrels per day every year.

Today we have about 6 million barrels of oil per day of spare capacity, mostly in the Middle East.  In a year and a half,  due to the natural decline rate of 4 million barrels per day, we will use up all the 6 million barrel spare capacity.

When that happens we will start down the back side of the world oil supply curve  — never to return. This means that every two and a half years we will need to find the equivalent of a Saudi Arabia (which produces a little more than 10 million barrels per day) just to keep up with aging and declining oil fields.

But it is estimated that we will only be able to bring on 2 million barrels per day in new production when we need 4 million barrels per day just to keep up with the aging oil fields. After we go through the spare capacity, in about a year and a half, we will then be short two million barrels per day every year after that. In short time we will see $200 oil. That will mean gas will be higher than $7 per gallon. It will cost more than $100 to fill a small car’s gas tank.

Folks who can afford to will leave the electric grid as fast as they can, leaving the rubbah slippah folks and small businesses to pay for the cost of the electric grid.  We cannot let that happen if we can avoid it.

Unlike most of the people in the world we in Hawai‘i are very fortunate; we do have a solution.

We can go to cheap geothermal for our base power. If we get cheap electricity as a result, then more people are apt to stay on the grid. Cheap electricity makes electric cars more attractive. More people on the grid spreads the cost of the grid, resulting in lower rates for everyone.

As we all know, it’s the folks on the lowest rungs of the economic ladder that will get their lights turned off first. It’s a good chance they will be our Hawaiian brothers and sisters.

We cannot let that happen and profess to value the Hawaiian culture.

And here is a practical benefit: When the price of oil rises over time, as we know it will, our stable electricity rates will make us relatively more competitive to the rest of the world. Our people will have a higher standard of living compared to others.

For the sake of our future generations here, let’s get off that oil train and switch to geothermal.

Many of our leaders know about the oil situation. But many of them are afraid to take a stand, fearing that it might be too controversial.

We will soon find out who our true leaders really are!

Energy Meetings

I’m getting myself up to speed for a Hawai‘i Clean Energy
Initiative
steering committee meeting on Thursday.

I’m on O‘ahu right now, for three days of meetings with
various energy-related Department of Business, Economic Development & Tourism working groups. They’ve been working on biofuels, electricity, end-use efficiency and transportation issues for a couple of years now. Among other things, I heard an update on various possible configurations of undersea cables.

These working groups will be handing off their work to the
steering committee for policy making and implementation.

The whole energy subject is very complex. I’m glad I bring a
farmer’s perspective; it helps me cut to the chase very quickly.

This is very interesting! And it is very serious business.

Touring the Maui Quarantine Inspection Facility

A couple weeks ago I went over to the Maui quarantine
inspection facility, which I was told is the best facility in the State for dealing with invasive species.

Master cho 2d trip 015

Kyle Yagi took me around and showed me how the facility works. First, it’s located right next to the commercial air cargo operators. So when air cargo arrives with produce, it travels just a short distance to a place where the air cargo containers are placed in a secure facility.

Master cho 2d trip 013

There are two rooms where several air containers can undergo simultaneous inspection
 The containers are opened up and inspectors go through each
box inspecting for invasive pests. This is all done in a secure area where insects, if found, cannot escape.

Master cho 2d trip 003

Giant bug light to attract any flying insects that might have escaped after inspections are completed

If the containers are found to be contaminated, the infested produce goes into an area where the temperature is set below freezing. That ensures that, when the minimum time elapses, all the insects are dead, and then the load is disposed of in the landfill.

Master cho 2d trip 012

A pallet of asparagus contaminated with invasive insect species

Master cho 2d trip 011

It’s being completely frozen until they are sure no insects survive; then they will dispose of it

The Department of Agriculture has told us that it is going to start posting the “frequency of contamination” on its website. Farmers would like to know what imported produce is routinely contaminated, so they can assess whether or not they can produce those products here.

It’s a very impressive facility. It would be good to have one at all the critical points of entry and departure.

Richard Appointed as Co-Chair of Working Group to Analyze Geothermal on Big Island

The Big Island Labor Alliance’s Geothermal Committee initiated SCR99:

REQUESTING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A WORKING GROUP TO ANALYZE THE POTENTIAL DEVELOPMENT OF GEOTHERMAL ENERGY AS THE PRIMARY ENERGY SOURCE TO MEET THE BASELOAD DEMAND FOR ELECTRICITY ON THE BIG ISLAND.

Senator Kokubun wrote the bill. It was heard at both houses’ energy committees, as well as the Senate’s Water, Land, Agriculture, and Hawaiian Affairs committees. It passed unanimously through all the committees.

I gave testimony to the Senate committees, pointing out that geothermal is the cheapest form of “base power.” I told them I am concerned that the utilities are encouraging the use of biofuels to power electric generators. Biofuels are much more expensive than geothermal-powered electricity. And it is the folks on the lowest rungs of the economic ladder who will get their lights turned off first, I reminded them, and that is most likely to be Hawaiians.

The County of Hawai‘i will be the lead agency, ensuring that this project will be accomplished in a timely manner. Mayor Billy Kenoi indicated that Wally Ishibashi and myself would be co-chairs of this working group. Wally and I work together seamlessly. We agree that we are both in favor of transparency and an open process.

The legislature wants a report 20 days before the start of the next legislative session. We will be ready to go in a few short weeks.

It is clear to us that we need to maximize geothermal energy. High electric rates don’t do anyone any good.

Here’s how SCR99 starts:

WHEREAS, in 1881, King David Kalakaua visited Thomas Edison  in New York to discuss extracting power from Hawaii’s volcanoes  and using underwater cables to carry power between islands; and

WHEREAS, at the time, his strategy did not prove to be
feasible, and hydropower was used to generate electricity to  light Honolulu; and

WHEREAS, today, technology advances make geothermal energy  not only feasible, but a top source of renewable energy; and

WHEREAS, geothermal energy is a more reliable source of
energy than solar or wind energy, because when the wind does not  blow and the sun does not shine, the heat from the volcano  continues to produce a steady flow of power; and

WHEREAS, Hawaii’s ratio of renewable energy generation (ten  per cent) to fossil fuel generation (ninety per cent) ranks  third in the nation; and

WHEREAS, the United States Department of Energy has
indicated that Hawaii is one of the best positioned states for  renewable energy potential; and…
read more