Last night the County Council held a meeting in Pahoa regarding geothermal, and hundreds of people attended.
The Pele Defense Fund was scheduled to speak for an hour, but they had at least an hour and a half’s worth of material.
Read about it at the Big Island Chronicle: Puna News – Dispatch of a County Council Geothermal Meeting in Pahoa.
While island-wide these days there is a great deal of support for geothermal, most of the testimony from these people in Pahoa, near the Puna Geothermal Venture plant, was against geothermal for religious and safety reasons.
Clearly, these issues need to be addressed.
I gave a short testimony in my role as a farmer. I talked about how I am the only person from Hawai‘i to have attended four Peak Oil conferences – because my farm costs were going up, due to the rising price of oil, and I wanted to learn as much as I could to help my farm adapt.
What I’ve learned has been very disturbing. I knew that I needed to transform my farm. But the burden of knowing that the world has been using twice as much oil as it had been finding for the last 20-30 years, and that this was going to continue, became my kuleana. I needed to inform people and also do something about it.
People might not have noticed, but in 2000 the oil price was $25 per barrel, and then it doubled to $50, and by the end of 2011 it was at $100/barrel. This means that the price of oil has doubled every 5.5 years.
If that continues, a family whose electric bill is $300 today can expect that in 5.5 years it will be close to $600/month. And when 11 years has gone by, it might approach $1,200/month.
Our families are struggling today; they will not be able to handle that added burden. They need relief now. We don’t have much time.
I pointed out that geothermal is estimated to cost 10 cents/kWh (according to a 2005 GeotherEx report), compared to electricity generated from oil, which costs more than 20 cents/kWh.
I said that I asked Jim Kauahikaua, Scientist-in-Charge at the Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, “How long will the Big Island be over the hot spot?” He replied, “500,000 to a million years.”
I said that we can expect electricity generated from oil, now at 20 cents/kWh, to double to 40 cents in 5.5 years and then to 80 cents/ kWh in 11 years – while geothermal would stay at 10 cents/kWh.
I told them what I asked Carl Bonham, head of the University of Hawaii Economic Research Organization. As oil prices rise, I asked, and if we were to use geothermal as our primary base power, would Hawaii then become more competitive with the rest of the world? He said yes.
My next question to him is close to my heart, because of the effect on the “rubbah slippah folks.”
“Is it fair to say that our standard of living would rise, relative to the rest of the world?” I asked.
“Yes,” he replied.
Aloha,
I’ve been following the various news feeds about HELCO and PGV for about one year. I attended a conference in Hilo last year where several presenters discussed energy going forward.
Aside from PGV resistance, it occurs to me that those proponents of alternative energy do not turn out in the numbers that opponents do, and the reason has to do with economics. Proponents of alternative energy solve the problem for themselves by going off-grid, leaving the masses to protest PGV.
My question, and I believe it’s a good one, is how will opponents pay for electricity as HELCO’s rates skyrocket? Even those who believe geothermal harvesting is akin to Pele’s rape will have to pay for energy, won’t they, or am I mistaken about that?